The oyster menu changes seasonally. Patrick McMurray brings in the most unusual oysters to Toronto. Patrick or one of his knowledgeable shucker is always on hand to explain their unique attributes.
Starfish offers an extensive selection of wine and beer including their signature Oyster Stout.
This Ain’t your Daddy’s Oyster Bar!
Paddy’s Favourite Oysters – from North America and The European Oyster Collection–Only found at Starfish. Oysters-Shucked to Order
North American Mixed Plate $12/$30
Shucker’s Bext Mix NA & Europe $12/$35
Sample Menu: Dowdle’s Green Gables (PEI), Kelly’s – Natives & Rocks (Ireland), English, French and Scottish…Pemaquid, Wellfleet and Kumamoto (US) to name a few…
Starfish Lunch Menu – Oceanwise
Sample menu: Daily Soup, House Smoked Irish Salmon, Blue Crab Salad Mojito Vinaigrette, Fish & Chips, Wild Striped Bass-Butternut Squash Hash, Ontario Rainbow Trout-Lobster Sweet Potato Puree, House made Desserts
Starfish Dinner Menu – Oceanwise
Weekend Lunches – $25 Prix Fixe and Oysterlicious Specials
Sample Menu: Mixed Baby Greens, Hogtown Chowder, Grilled Sardines, Confit Duck Rillettes, PEI Mussels withe House Frites, Aquiacultured PEI Halibut with Curried Cauliflower, Lake Huron Pickerel with Tomato Brodetto, Grilled Angus Ribeye Steak with House Frites, Whole Atlantic Lobster, Artisan Cheeses by Cheese Boutique
Oysterlicious Afternoons featuring Zinc & Drink
Monday through Friday, 3 to 6 p.m. | Weekends 12 noon to 6 p.m.
Canadian East Coast Plate $12/$15
Shucker’s Best Mix – NA & UK Oysters $12/$25
Add a drink for $5, Choice of a Pint of Guinness, Harp or Foundry, Glass of House Wine, The Iceberg StarfishTini or The Starfish Caesar!
Guinness, Harp, Foundry Cider & Local Craft Beer | Southern Ontario & Old World Wines | Cava, Crement & Champers | Iceberg StarfishTini, The Starfish Caesar, Oyster Shooters, Irish & Scottish Whisky
BYOWine – $20/bottle
We do change our menu daily, however we do not change our website daily. Prices subject to change, fresh seafood is always subject to availability – It’s just up to Mother Nature.